For a number of years now, I have been reviewing books, mostly children’s literature. This began when we had a few bad experiences with our children’s reading books that had been recommended by others but which we later found were inappropriate by our standards. Therefore, I determined to preview what they read. I have also reviewed other books related to homeschooling, parenting, apologetics, and similar topics. Most of these have been posted to various e-mail lists including Family Reads ( http://groups.yahoo.com/group/familyreads/ ). Some have been included in the weekly e-mail newsletter of Home School Buzz ( http://www.homeschoolbuzz.com ) and also Stories for Children, an e-zine ( http://storiesforchildren.tripod.com ). A few have even been published in homeschooling magazines (The Old Schoolhouse and on its website and Home School Enrichment). However, all of them are published each month in my monthly homeschooling newsletter, Biblical Homeschooling. Anyone who is interested may receive it by sending a blank e-mail to biblicalhomeschooling-subscribe@yahoogroups.com and following the instructions that will be sent in response or by subscribing on the web at http://groups.yahoo.com/group/biblicalhomeschooling/ .
Here are the reviews from the August, 2007, issue.
9. BOOK REVIEWS
(Note on language levels: 1. Nothing objectionable; 2. Common euphemisms; 3. Some cursing or profanity; 4. A lot of cursing or profanity; 5. Obscenity or vulgarity.)
Earnhart, Paul. Invitation to a Spiritual Revolution: Studies in the Sermon on the Mount (published in 1999 by Gary Fisher, 2685 W. Riley Rd., Floyd Knobs, IN 47119). The author is a gospel preacher who currently lives in Louisville, KY, and works with the Douglas Hills church of Christ. I first met him in 1977 when he spoke at the annual lectures of the Thayer St. church in Akron, OH, where I was then laboring. While we have never had the opportunity to have close association through the years, our paths have crossed several times since then, and I consider him among my personal friends. In all of our limited relations, he has always been a source of encouragement to me. In fact, the last time I recall seeing him, he must have heard that we were homeschooling and said that it was the right way to go. Four years prior to my meeting him, he had presented a series of lessons about the Sermon on the Mount at the Thayer St. lectures, and beginning in 1975 continued in succeeding years to deliver such lessons to scores of congregations throughout the nation to great reception. Over a period of three years, he wrote articles on this same subject in Christianity Magazine, of which he served as an editor from its beginning in 1984. These articles were collected and put together to form this book. I recall reading and enjoying the articles when they first came out, but it was very refreshing to read them again in book form. Most of the books reviewed in this newsletter fall into the category of literature, and I usually avoid including books of a purely "religious" nature unless they are to be highly recommended. This book falls into that classification. Its 56 relatively short chapters could easily serve as a good source for daily devotionals or as part of a Bible curriculum for deeper study of the passage. The Sermon on the Mount contains some of the most fundamental teachings of our Lord Jesus Christ. Anyone who is interested in developing a better understanding of these basic principles, not just with theoretical knowledge but with practical application, will benefit from this book. Language level: 1. Ages: teens and adults. EXCELLENT.
Hyman, Mac. No Time for Sergeants (published in 1954 by Random House Inc.; republished in 1956 as a Signet Book by The New American Library of World Literature Inc., 501 Madison Ave., New York City, NY 10022). I picked up this book at a library used book sale because I recognized the title. Years ago, we watched on television the movie, starring Andy Griffith, that was based on this book, and I remembered it being very funny. It is the story about a drawling, easy-going Georgia boy named Will Stockdale who was drafted into the United States Army and assigned to the Army Air Corps during World War II. With his new friend Ben Whitledge, he gets in all kinds of misadventures involving officers, KP, latrine duty, and an induction-center psychiatrist. There is even a Mark Twain-Tom Sawyerish twist where Will and Ben attend their own "posthumous" medal awards ceremony after a plane crash. Ira Levin adapted the novel for a play which originally appeared as an episode on The United States Steel Hour television series in March 1955, starring Andy Griffith. It was later adapted into a popular Broadway play that opened later that year, again starring Griffith along with Don Knotts, and closed in 1957. The film version, which also included Knotts, was made in 1958 and was largely responsible for launching the careers of Griffith and Knotts. The setting for the film was updated to reflect the peacetime forces of the 50’s and the characters were members of the now separate United States Air Force. No Time for Sergeants came to the small screen as a short-lived ABC television series in the fall of 1964, starring Sammy Jackson, which lasted only one season. However, it was also the inspiration for the much more famous CBS television series Gomer Pyle, U.S.M.C. which aired from 1964-1969. Someone noted, "A bigger problem is that No Time for Sergeants AND Gomer Pyle BOTH ripped off their premise from The Good Soldier Schweik, a novel that is very famous in Europe but which appears to be utterly unknown to everyone in America (except the guy who ripped it off for these two TV shows). Schweik is a moronic klutz of an army private who just wants to be ‘a good soldier’, but his efforts to please his sergeant only reap disaster." The book is definitely funny. Bennett Cerf, a popular reviewer of the time, wrote, "I always thought ‘I laughed till I cried’ was just a figure of speech–until I read this book! It’s a four-star, one hundred per cent wowser." A lot of the humor is a bit crude by refined standards, and some of it would be considered politically incorrect today. However, for a book about military life there is surprisingly no vulgarity or obscenity, and very little bad language. The "h" and "d" words each appear once, except that toward the end of the book the term "God-d" is used a couple of times. However, the terms "by God" and "Lord" are used frequently as interjections (which is taking the name of the Lord in vain). There are numerous references to drinking alcohol, smoking tobacco, and gambling. This would not be a good book for small children, but older teenagers and adults, especially those who are interested in things military, might enjoy it. Language level: 3. Ages: 16 and up. GOOD.
McAllister, M. I. Urchin and the Heartstone (Mistmantle Chronicles Book Two, published in 2006 by Hyperion Books for Children, 114 Fifth Ave., New York City, NY 10011). We have read Book One in the "Mistmantle Chronicles," Urchin of the Riding Stars, in which Urchin the squirrel rescued Crispin who was unjustly exiled by the evil Captain Husk in his attempt to overthrow King Brushen of Mistmantle Island, and we really enjoyed it. In Book Two, Urchin is kidnapped by emissaries of the deranged King Silverbirch of Whitewings Island to be a slave in the silver mines, while back on Mistmantle the Heartstone has been lost so that Crispin’s coronation as the new king cannot take place and there is a revolt against Crispin by some hedgehogs. Will Urchin be able to help the enslaved islanders of Whitewings, escape himself, and get back home to help find the Heartstone? M. I McAllister is the wife of a minister and lives with her family in England. This book is recommended for readers ages 8 to 12 who like fantasy and, as one reviewer said, would be especially good for children who are not quite ready for Brian Jacques’s "Redwall" series, which we happen to like also. Language level: 1. Ages: 8-12. EXCELLENT. (Note: This review first appeared in Stories for Children Magazine, June, 2007; http://storiesforchildren.tripod.com ).
Nappa, Mike. Tuesdays With Matthew (copyrighted in 2003 by Nappaland Communications Inc. and published by River Oak Publishing, an imprint of Cook Communications Ministries, 4050 Lee Vance View, Colorado Springs, CO 80918). To be honest, I purchased this book only because I needed another couple of dollars on an order to take advantage of a special offer and CBD had a fiction package of this one and another for $2.00. It is somewhat of an odd book, but overall I enjoyed it and think that it has a useful purpose. Apparently, it is an attempt to base a fiction book upon what is called "relational apologetics." Photographer Todd Striker is a thirty-something disillusioned son of a minister. He experienced some rather unpleasant situations as a child in his "church career," had some doubts and questions that were never satisfactorily answered, quit going to church when he was in college, and then suffered the untimely death of his father to cancer. A couple of angels arrange for Todd to spend twelve Tuesdays with the apostle Matthew. Todd asks various questions about miracles, Satan, prayer, purpose, pain, wealth, faith, greatness, honesty, failure, and love, and Matthew answers them, mostly by relating stories about Jesus from the book of Matthew. Matthew’s explanations remind Todd of various in his life when the principles enunciated were applicable. There are some denominational concepts and terminology used in the book with which non-denominational Christians would disagree (calling the preacher "pastor," instrumental music in worship, observing Christmas as the birth of Christ, and the definition of miracle), but aside from these there are some beneficial concepts to be found in it. Norm Wakefield, a homeschooling father of four, founder of The Spirit of Elijah Ministries International, and frequent homeschool conference speaker, recommends this book, saying, "A unique blend of creativity, wisdom and warmth make Tuesdays With Matthew a delight to read! Mike Nappa’s novel left me with a sense of our Lord’s presence." Language level: 1. Ages: older teens and adults. GOOD.
Paul, Donita K. The "Dragon Keeper" series (published by Waterbrook Press, 2375 Telstar Dr., Suite 160, Colorado Springs, CO 80920, a division of Random House Inc.). These books were recommended in both the 6/05 and 3/06 issues of this newsletter. Our son Mark, age 16, read them and his review appears in the 1/07 issue. I just finished them and think that they are great. Wulder is the Creator of all things, including the seven high races who inhabit the continent of Amara. The leader of Wulder’s forces is Paladin, along with good wizards such as Fenworth and Cam Ayronn. The enemy is The Pretender, who calls himself Lord Ire, and those in his service include bad wizards Risto, Crim Cropper, and Burner Stox. And, of course, there are all kinds of dragons. In DragonSpell (2004), Kale, an orphaned orant slave girl, finds a dragon egg and because of her ability to bond with it is sent to Paladin’s Hall. After being attached by grawligs, she is rescued by the marione General Lee Ark, the emerlindian Leetu Bends, the doneel Dar, and the urohm Brunstetter, and goes with them on a quest to find Wizard Fenworth and rescue a meech dragon egg that Risto has stolen to increase his power and then joins in the battle against Risto’s forces. In DragonQuest (2005), Kale is joined by her friends, the newly hatched meech dragon Regidor, and her monitor Bardon, on a quest to rescue another meech dragon, free other enslaved dragons, and thwart Risto’s plans. She also begins seeing visions of her mother and statements are made which lead her to believe that her mother is still alive. Will she ever find her? In Dragon Knight (2006) Bardon must go on his own quest to help an elderly emerlindian and her granddaughter find the girl’s father who has been imprisoned by Risto. Eventually, he is joined by Kale and both find out many secrets about their past. Kathy Davis of HomeSchoolBuzz.com had written about DragonSpell, "Imaginative world, adventurous quest, unusual characters, and dangerous foes do make a reliable recipe for a good fantasy read. In DragonSpell, the author has all these ingredients, and delivers it as a Christian allegory. Former slave-girl Kale has a gift for finding and caring for dragons. When she’s called upon to retrieve a stolen rare dragon egg, Kale must face doubts, trials, and peril as she discovers the true purpose of her gift. The book is fresh, and contains nothing objectionable. It’s not a perfectly crafted novel–the plot meanders at times and the metaphors are obvious. Still, I have no hesitation in recommending this book; it’s nice to find a story that helps kids with their faith. Anyone who craves fantasy will enjoy DragonSpell, and will be looking forward to reading the sequel, DragonQuest." I really enjoyed the books and while I can see where the plot did meander at times (my wife also read them and said she noticed it especially in DragonKnight), I had trouble in putting them down. I think I finished all three in less than a couple of weeks (and they’re not small books!), My feeling was that, meaning no disrespect to Mrs. Paul, I doubt that anyone would confuse her with J. R. R. Tolkien or C. S. Lewis, but I found the books really interesting and refreshing; there was a sort of "Lord of the Rings" feeling about them. As Kathy says, there is nothing objectionable (except a few references to drinking ale, and it could be "ginger ale"). Language level: 1. Ages: grades 4-8. EXCELLENT. (Note: Some of my comments on this book appeared in the June 7, 2007, issue of the HomeSchoolBuzz.com newsletter; if you would like to subscribe, go to http://homeschoolbuzz.com )
Ware, Jim. Canyon Quest: The Exciting Start of the Last Chance Detectives (copyrighted in 2004 by Focus on the Family, 8605 Explorer Dr., Colorado Springs, CO 80902, and published by Tyndale House Publishers Inc., Wheaton, IL). Twelve-year-old Mike Fowler hates living in Ambrosia, AZ. While the Fowlers were living in Ohio six years earlier, his father was missing after an F-16 crash, so he and his mother had to move to live with his father’s parents in Ambrosia. Mike is just about ready to "run away" back to see his best friend in Ohio when he finds his father’s old journal in the B-17 that his grandfather has parked out behind the family’s "Last Chance" diner and gas station. While doing some research on what his father did as a young boy, he meets Ben, a local boy who believes in Martians and can give him a ride to the nearby Lowell Observatory where Mike’s father hung out a lot during his childhood; Spence, another local boy who is homeschooled and is studying astronomy; and Winnie, a local Navajo girl who knows the countryside very well. Together, while looking for evidence of what Mike’s dad might have done in his youth, they investigate some strange goings on in the canyons around Ambrosia. Are they caused by Martians? or the spirits of the ancient Anasazi enemies of the Navajo? or maybe a top-secret military operation that might even involve Mike’s missing dad? The story is very exciting, especially towards the end. "The Last Chance Detectives" is a Focus on the Family audio cassette and DVD series. This book explains how the four friends came to become the Last Chance Detectives. Jim Ware has written other books, such as God of the Fairy Tale: Finding Truth in the Land of Make Believe; Finding God in the Lord of the Rings; and Finding God in the Land of Narnia. Language level: 1. Ages: 12 and up. EXCELLENT. (Note: This review first appeared in Stories for Children Magazine, June, 2007; http://storiesforchildren.tripod.com )